Copycat Cutwater Pina Colada Recipe

9

A Pina Colada is more than just a drink; it’s a moment of bliss in a glass. And when it comes to nailing that perfect tropical flavor, Cutwater Pina Colada has set itself apart with its smooth, ready-to-enjoy marvel straight from the can.

How to make a Cutwater Pina Colada

Cutwater Piña Colada is a ready-to-drink canned cocktail made by Cutwater Spirits, inspired by the classic tropical piña colada.

Ingredients

Core Ingredients:

• Cutwater Rum (White Rum or Spiced Rum): 2 ounces
• Pineapple Juice: 2 ounces
• Cream of Coconut: 2 ounces (such as Coco López for an authentic taste)
• Ice: 1 cup (or more for a thicker, blended drink)

Optional Additions:

• Lime Juice: ½ ounce for a zesty twist
• Pineapple Chunks: A few fresh or frozen pieces to enhance the fruity profile
• Vanilla Extract: ¼ teaspoon for added depth

Garnishes:

• Pineapple Wedge: A fresh wedge for that tropical finishing touch
• Maraschino Cherry: Classic garnish to sweeten the visuals
• Shredded Coconut: Sprinkle on top for extra flair

Instructions

Here’s how to mix and blend your perfect Cutwater Pina Colada:

1. Prep Your Blender: Start by adding Cutwater Rum, pineapple juice, cream of coconut, and ice to your blender. If you’re using optional ingredients like lime juice or pineapple chunks, toss them in now too.
2. Blend Until Smooth: Blend on high speed until the cocktail is creamy and thick. This usually takes 20-30 seconds, depending on your blender and ice consistency.
3. Taste & Adjust: Before pouring, take a small sip to ensure the balance of flavors. If it’s too sweet, add a splash of lime juice. If the coconut isn’t strong enough, add a touch more cream of coconut.
4. Serve in Style: Pour your Pina Colada into a chilled glass, preferably a hurricane glass or tiki mug for maximum tropical vibes.
5. Garnish: Add a pineapple wedge, a maraschino cherry, and a sprinkle of shredded coconut on top. For extra fun, throw in a colorful cocktail umbrella or straw!

Tips for the Ultimate Cutwater Pina Colada

• Use Quality Rum: Cutwater’s rum is a premium choice that brings smoothness and complexity to your cocktail. Don’t skimp on the rum—its quality makes all the difference!
• Don’t Substitute Cream of Coconut: While coconut milk or syrup might seem appealing, the rich texture and sweetness of cream of coconut are key to a true Pina Colada flavor.
• Experiment with Ice: If you prefer your Pina Colada extra thick, add more ice or use frozen pineapple chunks for a frostier consistency.
• Try a Non-Alcoholic Version: If you’re hosting guests who prefer a mocktail, simply omit the rum or replace it with coconut water for a light and refreshing alternative.
• Blend Ahead of Time: Hosting a party? Blend a large batch and keep it in the fridge until ready to serve. Just give it a quick stir before pouring.
• Presentation Matters: Garnishes like pineapple wedges, cherries, and coconut shreds give your Pina Colada a professional touch, making your drink as Instagram-worthy as it is delicious!

What to serve with

The Cutwater Pina Colada is a creamy, sweet, and tropical delight that deserves the perfect food pairings to amplify its island vibes.

1. Coconut Shrimp: Crispy coconut shrimp is a match made in tropical heaven. The crunchy, slightly sweet coconut coating complements the creamy coconut notes of the cocktail, while the tangy dipping sauce (like mango chili or pineapple salsa) adds a balanced zing.

2. Spicy Chicken Wings: Spicy or buffalo-style chicken wings are a fantastic pairing to cut through the sweetness of the drink. The heat from the wings provides a nice counterpoint to the smooth, fruity flavors of the Pina Colada.

3. Guacamole & Chips: A bowl of fresh guacamole with tortilla chips or plantain chips provides an earthy, citrusy flavor that complements the tropical vibes of the drink. Squeeze extra lime into the guac for a tangy boost that mirrors the zesty pineapple notes.

Ingredients Substitutes

While the classic Cutwater Pina Colada recipe hits the sweet spot of coconut, pineapple, and rum flavors, you might need to make substitutions based on the ingredients available or your personal preferences.

1. Cutwater Rum (or Any White/Spiced Rum)

Cutwater’s rum is the backbone of this cocktail, but if it’s unavailable, you have options:

• Substitute with Any Other Rum: Use a quality white rum (for a light and tropical flavor) or spiced rum (to add warm notes of vanilla, cinnamon, or nutmeg). For a stronger punch, opt for dark rum.
• Coconut Rum (e.g., Malibu): For an extra coconut-forward cocktail, replace white rum with coconut rum to enhance the Pina Colada’s signature flavor.
• Non-Alcoholic Option: Skip the rum altogether for a virgin Pina Colada or substitute with coconut water for a tropical twist without the booze. Non-alcoholic rum alternatives, like Ritual Zero Proof Rum, can also provide that familiar flavor without the alcohol content.

2. Cream of Coconut

Cream of coconut (e.g., Coco López) is a key ingredient that gives the Pina Colada its rich, creamy texture and sweet coconut flavor. However, it’s not always available in every kitchen or grocery store.

• Coconut Milk: A thinner substitute but still flavorful. Use full-fat coconut milk and add a sweetener (e.g., simple syrup or condensed milk) to mimic the richness and sweetness of cream of coconut.
• Coconut Cream: This is thicker than coconut milk and works as a decent alternative when mixed with some sugar or sweetened condensed milk.
• Sweetened Condensed Milk (Non-Coconut): Use a couple of tablespoons if you don’t mind skipping the coconut flavor altogether. To bring back the tropical feel, add a drop or two of coconut extract.
• Heavy Cream + Coconut Extract: Blend or mix heavy cream with a bit of coconut extract for a quick and easy substitute.

3. Pineapple Juice

Pineapple juice is the heart of the fruity flavor in a Pina Colada, and it’s best to use freshly squeezed juice. But if fresh or canned pineapple juice isn’t available, here’s how you can substitute:

• Frozen or Fresh Pineapple Chunks (Blended): Blend pineapple chunks with water until smooth and use that as a substitute for pineapple juice. This also adds a thicker texture to your drink.
• Mango or Orange Juice: Though not quite as tangy, mango or orange juice can substitute pineapple juice for a tropical spin. They add sweetness and a refreshing citrus note.
• Cranberry-Pineapple Juice Blend: If you have cranberry-pineapple juice on hand, it works as a suitable replacement while adding a slightly tart flavor.

4. Ice

Ice is primarily used to give the blended Pina Colada its frosty, smoothie-like consistency. But depending on what texture you’re aiming for, substitutions are possible:

• Frozen Pineapple Chunks: Skip or reduce the ice and use frozen pineapple chunks instead to keep the drink cold while intensifying the fruity flavor.
• Crushed Ice: Crushed ice helps blend the drink more evenly and produces a smoother texture, especially in a smaller blender.

5. Garnishes

While garnishes aren’t mandatory, they transform your Pina Colada into a show-stopping tropical drink. If you don’t have traditional garnishing ingredients, here are alternatives:

• Pineapple Wedge Alternative: Use an orange or lime wedge for a fresh pop of color and citrus zest.
• Shredded Coconut Substitute: Replace shredded coconut with edible flowers or a small amount of whipped cream for extra flair.
• Cherry Replacement: Use fresh berries, like a strawberry or raspberry, for a garnish you can eat.
• No Garnishes? No Problem: A colorful paper straw, cocktail umbrella, or even just a fun glass can substitute for traditional garnishes and give your drink a festive vibe.

6. Sweeteners

If your chosen ingredients leave your Pina Colada less sweet than desired, you can adjust the sweetness levels with these options:

• Honey or Agave Syrup: Healthy, natural substitutes that add subtle floral or earthy tones to your drink.
• Simple Syrup: A mix of equal parts sugar and water, this is a neutral way to increase sweetness without changing the flavor.
• Maple Syrup: For a unique and natural sweetener, maple syrup adds depth but should be used sparingly.

Final Thoughts

Making a homemade Cutwater Pina Colada is incredibly simple, yet the results are outrageously indulgent.

More Cutwater Recipes:

• Copycat Cutwater Lime Margarita Recipe
• Copycat Cutwater White Russian Recipe